After some time in court it appears as though the decision is final – Microsoft will have to pay i4i US$240 million after losing a second appeal. Last year it was found that Microsoft had infringed upon several XML-related patents owned by Canadian company i4i and so had to pay damages. Microsoft appealed this and lost, so they filed another appeal and lost once more.
The judges apparently explained to Microsoft why the decision was final: the court has evidence to suggest that Microsoft knew of and willingly infringed the patents with the hope that i4i’s product would become obsolete with Word 11. Court documents and a company email support this idea. Microsoft is now waiting for court appeal judges to see whether they can have a wider review of the case, or they may take the case to the Supreme Court.













